How Companies Report a Business They Are Exiting Is a Choice, and Investors See Through It
Firms can report a discontinued business as one net number or split it into operating results and the gain or loss on disposal. Managers' choices follow predictable psychology, but investors value the firm the same either way.

When a company sells or shuts down a line of business, the results of that business are pulled out of ongoing operations and reported separately as discontinued operations. What the rules do not fully settle is how much detail to show. A firm can report a single net figure. Or it can show two: what the business earned or lost while it was still running, and the gain or loss on getting rid of it.
A study by Binod Guragai, associate professor of accounting, with co-authors Weerapat Attachot and S. Drew Peabody, asks what drives that choice and whether it matters to investors. It was published in Advances in Accounting.
The study
This kind of presentation detail is not captured in standard financial databases. The researchers collected it by hand, reading the income statements of U.S. firms and recording whether each one aggregated its discontinued operations into one line or broke the figures apart.
They then tested two things. First, what predicts whether managers combine or separate the numbers. Second, whether investors price discontinued operations differently depending on the format.
What the researchers found
Managers’ choices are not random. The preference for showing the pieces separately follows patterns consistent with two ideas from behavioral economics.
Prospect theory holds that people feel losses more sharply than gains of the same size. Mental accounting holds that people sort outcomes into separate mental buckets, and that how gains and losses are grouped changes how they feel. Together, the theories predict that a person presenting mixed news will care about whether good and bad items appear side by side or folded into one number. The managers in this study behaved as those theories predict.
Investors did not respond in kind. The researchers found no evidence that the market’s valuation of discontinued operations differed between the combined and the broken-out presentations. Whatever managers hoped to achieve through format, it did not show up in how the stock was priced.
What it means for managers, regulators, and investors
For managers, the finding is a caution against spending effort on framing. The format of this line item reflects how the preparer feels about the numbers more than it shapes how readers value them.
For standard setters, it shows that the latitude in current rules is being used, and used systematically. That is relevant to any debate about whether to require one format.
For investors and analysts, the result is reassuring. The information reaches the price either way. It also suggests that when a firm chooses to break the figures out, the choice itself says something about how management views the exit.
This summary is based on the paper’s abstract. The full article reports the sample, measures, and detailed results.
What it means for managers
- Presentation is a management decision. Accounting rules leave room in how discontinued operations appear on the income statement, and managers use that room in patterned ways.
- The pattern is psychological. Choices to split or combine the numbers are consistent with prospect theory and mental accounting, which describe how people prefer to frame gains and losses.
- The market is not fooled. Investors valued discontinued operations no differently whether the figures were combined or broken out.
Guragai, B., Attachot, W., & Peabody, S. D. (2020). Financial statement presentation of discontinued operations: Determinants and consequences. Advances in Accounting, 49, 100472. 10.1016/j.adiac.2020.100472


